Skip to content




Markets Collapsing or Errors Amplified?

If you looked at today’s S&P 500 chart, you would have thought there was another massive terrorist attack.  Instead, we have riots in the streets of Greece….the 28th economy of a world, making up a massive .57% of world GDP.  And what about Portugal you say?  They are the 37th.  I am not trying to make light of this, but a weaker Euro is not so bad.  It allows the United States to inflate its way out of its debt problems, the strength in the dollar reduces the disparity between the Renminbi and the dollar, and goods from Europe (along with European vacations) are much cheaper.

The downside?  Fear, plus the fact that US goods look much more expensive to European consumers.  I was curious about this factor and its magnitude to US global corporations.  According to S&P, Global sales accounted for 45.8% of sales in 2007.  Europe accounted for 28.8% of those sales and the UK made up 4.6% of that.  Therefore, about 24% comes from the European Union.  The Euro has dropped by about 11% from the average trading level since the beginning of 2007, so with some rough math we might be able to say that 2.64% of S&P 500 earnings could be hurt by a fall in the Euro?  On the flip side, European goods have become much cheaper.

Euro average of 1.4078, currently trading at a discount of 11% at 1.26

So what actually happened today?  The rumor floating around is that 1,000,000,000 shares of Procter & Gamble were sold by a Citigroup trader instead of 1,000,000.  A billion instead of a million.  The rather ridiculously common error known as a “fat-fingered” trade.  You would think that risk monitoring would be put in place to stop such a heinous trade and it certainly does not raise your confidence in Citigroup.  Citigroup denies the rumor.

I was looking for a bounce off of the 2008 trend line, but instead it blasted right through

The big news of the day was the massive bidding up of option volatility.  The VIX spiked to an intraday high of 40%.

VIX spikes to 40%

You might call me stubborn, but I do not see this as a systemic failure of the markets, but the onslaught of technical volatility.  I call it “technical” volatility because the markets have become very much self-fulfilling in the last decade.  Much of the daily trading is done by hedge funds which jump on rallies or declines, by hedgers who push the market in whatever direction it is going and by mass exodus due to the rather recent ability to quickly move money in 401-k’s and brokerage accounts electronically.  When the market declines, the selling drives further declines and when the market rebounds, it rebounds faster.

I am not crawling into my bunker just yet, as a strong unemployment number and a good outcome to the European voting tomorrow could spur a quick rebound.

Be Sociable, Share!

Posted in Derivatives, Economics, Markets, Media, Technical Analysis, Trading Ideas.

Tagged with , , , , , , , .


8 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Rich Gane says

    A crazy day! Always enjoy your articles Surly. Cheers, Rich.

  2. Filiberto Rodriguez says

    “So what actually happened today? The rumor floating around is that 1,000,000,000 shares of Procter & Gamble were sold by a Citigroup trader instead of 1,000,000. A billion instead of a million.”

    This rumor is just that a simple rumor without a prove, we should know that this doesn’t happen in a trading desk. It simply imposible, there are many locks in the sistems that protect the trading desk from making this kind of mistakes. I know this because I work in a trading desk…

    I think that all this was more a problem of the Quant Funds fumbling the math model just miss, but I have no data to prove it.

  3. SurlyTrader says

    I am getting some contradictions as far as the Citigroup trade. Some are saying it was in P&G, some are saying it was in the S&P futures. Regardless of what the cause was, there was a systemic failure. 6 stocks traded at zero during the day – EXC,CNP,EXP,BRO,IWA, and CNP. I don’t know what happened, but it does not feel right. Nasdaq is cancelling all trades below 60% down, but that is simply a plug. I trust that there are stop measures at each of the banks and I am sure that you know better than most.

  4. Filiberto Rodriguez says

    Surly, take a look at the JPYUSD, and check how it trade, and when. The JPYUSD trade like a crash was coming before the S&P crash…. at the please take you own conclusion on this…

Continuing the Discussion

  1. Market Crash and Rebound: HFT Problems, Audio of Crash, Where Things Stand, David Kotok and Art Cashin, Paul Kedrosky, Mark Cuban, Kid Dynamite, 60% Robots | N2PQ Mortgage News and Information Network linked to this post on May 11, 2010

    […] Markets Collapsing or Errors Amplified? – (has logic and this conclusion) … You might call me stubborn, but I do not see this as a systemic failure of the markets, but the onslaught of technical volatility. I call it “technical” volatility because the markets have become very much self-fulfilling in the last decade.  Much of the daily trading is done by hedge funds which jump on rallies or declines, by hedgers who push the market in whatever direction it is going and by mass exodus due to the rather recent ability to quickly move money in 401-k’s and brokerage accounts electronically.  When the market declines, the selling drives further declines and when the market rebounds, it rebounds faster. … – Surly Trader […]

  2. So the World is Not Ending? | SurlyTrader linked to this post on May 11, 2010

    […] default contagion.  From the United States’ perspective, Europe (UK excluded) makes up about 24% of S&P 500 company sales.  A drop in the Euro will hurt those sales, but they will not go to […]

  3. The World’s Not Ending: Where to Invest? | Top Equity News linked to this post on May 12, 2010

    […] default contagion. From the United States’ perspective, Europe (UK excluded) makes up about 24% of S&P 500 company sales. A drop in the euro will hurt those sales, but they will not go to […]

  4. Put Spreads as an Attractive Hedge | SurlyTrader linked to this post on April 27, 2011

    […] be setting us up for a summer market correction followed by the announcement of QE3.  I remember May 5, 2010 quite well and I hope you do […]



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.



Get Adobe Flash player
Copyright © 2009-2013 SurlyTrader DISCLAIMER The commentary on this blog is not meant to be taken as an investment advice. The author is not a registered investment adviser. There is no substitute for your own due diligence. Please be aware that investing is inherently a risky business and if you chose to follow any of the advice on this site, then you are accepting the risks associated with that investment. The Author may have also taken positions in the stocks or investments that are being discussed and the author may change his position at any time without warning.

Yellow Pages for USA and Canada SurlyTrader - Blogged

ypblogs.com